North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Pingable IPs on backbones?

  • From: Christopher A. Woodfield
  • Date: Tue Jan 30 17:03:48 2001

I just had one of those "duh" experiences today, and it made me think a 
bit...

At my job at <vijay> a promising local ISP </vijay>, I was turning up a 
customer, who decided to test his connectivity by trying to ping and trace 
to www.sprint.net and www.uu.net. As it turns out, both servers are behind 
firewalls, that block ICMP and UDP, so you can't ping or trace to either 
server. But then my customer asked me, "OK, can you give me a hostname in 
UU's netspace that I CAN ping?" It took some thought and experimentation 
to find one (mail.uu.net and ns1.sprint.net, in case anyone wants to 
know).

What this brought to mind was this question: would it be worth my time to 
compile a list of pingable and traceable IPs that live on the major 
backbones for connectivity testing and troubleshooting? I do wind up 
seeing a lot of cloobies trying to ping a site, and assuming it's down 
because IMCP-blocked.

Thoughts?

-C

---------------------------
Christopher A. Woodfield		[email protected]

PGP Public Key: http://pgp.mit.edu:11371/pks/lookup?op=get&search=0xB887618B