North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: Best utilizing fat long pipes and large file transfer

  • From: Glen Turner
  • Date: Sun Jun 15 23:10:37 2008
  • Face: iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAADAAAAAwBAMAAAClLOS0AAAALVBMVEV8hICwZ1odCw7OiXlO ODMEBAvgy8WynJtXR2ZLIy+SWk2yeGL///8fHyx4QDQ69jxnAAACY0lEQVQ4jY3TMWsbMRQAYA8l 9pDlyHa3iXjIkMHc0MFQKGjwmZ6nHu2SrTS0eEip6ZW0gQyldaGB1tyiIYGb0jyXg+OGwAlCh2IH 4qGYmsTQGwJarIJ+QyXbyclNC32jPj1JT08qDP4Rhf+B3t+hv5dlF8Wb8HLoqTj/A3p73jyWF6E1 uoKHC9DPyl5ZDZevU2bwbVhGSMnGyHugww5CY4JUDL2NpgYuGgc46AynaT9z6LtrgRAN5uwj5M3X msJpRgSAABeplPs5PBkLMC0wjtBUmtfQqgNYNKSGQ9B62Xt9DbfqZphUEpuaYj8bzSqZQRiv3H5u 21UzcvYzLaPUTWwV1FCQaRlziI0IL0DrCsyIZVmWL/XIoleAF+DUAOjKMzHByDj7kcPXlANP4khe yjrJah/yu0qB8ZVKgwVsGLgXGtDwc2jf+WTBBBP3/Zd8qaRKLfvkLjU5sHYn3+NM3kZSPeE2pTBp rw10kGVLsCvRpLSqNUqVITMSO46c0vdFqCYnQgIj7Xs3wPllpxKWc+hZNI7DI3RpmROyqz+fMO5S 0w14aDrkrQ5pCqEFEeOASVGHbSuuhyZDl2mACzo8pTQ+phE30oNaSYe+hJUK8DBt1N680KDXpVQ2 nEMkanqjBoNnEmIAub+L1s81OLMkmCCE00HehQb9kCYxRBg78o3uarAJNJE9J5iQzmppOQcfuqoX ErDzsfQuP9UrDiZEDnYOBDtsF5tzeOxv10EwjHHAQWwViksz2PT9nUu1M3YaHA63fL+goOfL2OrK HyVFhMaxgqVBYTru+1QVIYT8P9N5xeZvAufMcHaieZQAAAAASUVORK5CYII=
  • List-archive: <http://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog>
  • List-help: <mailto:[email protected]?subject=help>
  • List-id: North American Network Operators Group <nanog.nanog.org>
  • List-post: <mailto:[email protected]>
  • List-subscribe: <http://mailman.nanog.org/mailman/listinfo/nanog>, <mailto:[email protected]?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <http://mailman.nanog.org/mailman/listinfo/nanog>, <mailto:[email protected]?subject=unsubscribe>

[email protected] wrote:

Its actually not that hard on windows.

Don't make me laugh. Instructions that start


"Enable TCP window scaling and time stamps by using the Registry Editor
to browse to location
 [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Tcpip\Parameters]
and add the key
  Tcp1323Opts
with value
  3"

are "hard".  If you think otherwise, pick up the phone, pretend to
work for an ISP Help Desk, and walk someone who doesn't work in IT
through the changes.

Microsoft scatter the tuning information for Windows Xp all across
their website. Some of it is undocumented by Microsoft (and thus may
change without notice). The only saving grace is DrTCP, a third party
application which hides all of the registry detail (and potential for
disaster) under a nice GUI.

Then there's the deliberate nobbling of the TCP implementation,
such as the restriction to ten of connections to Windows Xp SP3.
Apparently you're meant to buy Windows Server if you are running
P2P applications :-)

Windows Vista is a vast improvement over Windows Xp (and I bet that
isn't said of many components of Vista). It has a autotuning TCP with
a 16MB buffer, which makes the defaults fine for ADSL and cable, but
still requires machines at universities to be altered.  Vista offers
an alternative TCP congestion control algorithm -- Compound TCP. Not
much is known of the performance attributes of this algorithm, mainly
because I.P claims prevented its incorporation into Linux, the corral
where most TCP algorithm shoot-outs take place.

--
 Glen Turner