North American Network Operators Group Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical Re: VOIP and QOS across local network and the Internet
I've thought long and hard about this, mostly from the perspective of regional ILECs too small to implement MPLS. QoS should be sold in 80k 'channel' increments. You, the carrier, don't care what the customer is marking as DSCP EF, you just accept and accelerate the first 80k x number of channels, then treat the rest as best effort. There should be a cost here as you have various management tasks - its not fire and forget like best effort service. Your interior must prioritize the DSCP EF marked traffic ... but you open up the capacity engineering worm on your network. Can you easily predict maximums along paths and ensure they'll never be topped? Do you have queueing on all routers and switches that is rigged to support the plan? The return path is *always* the problem. Sure, they can mark, you can accept, but how does the return sound? Do ISPs honor QoS markings across their network? Not the ones I touch, because they've often got public IP and private voice data riding in the same 802.1Q trunk, even though they may hit separate routers. Its a big puzzle and the prize goes to whom ever figures out how to do it nice and neat in both directions. The big prize is, of course, declining voice profits as voice transitions to being just another internet app with no need for the regulated, media gateway & TDM telco world. At the end of the day the only phone companies left standing are going to be those who provide wireless phones, as there is significant capital investment required in such a plant. The wireline voice carriers are all going to slowly spiral into being nothing but ISPs. Hello all,
|