North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: ICANNs role [was: Re: On-going ...]

  • From: John Levine
  • Date: Tue Apr 03 09:03:46 2007

>I think the shutdown of seclists.org by GoDaddy is a perfect example of 
>exactly why the registrars should NOT be making these decisions.

I know the head abuse guy at Godaddy.  He is a reasonable person.  He
turns off large numbers of domains but he is human and makes the
occasional mistake.  The fact that everyone cites the same mistake
tells me that he doesn't make very many of them.  If you demand that
the shutdown process be perfect and never make any mistakes ever, even
ones that involve peculiar e-mail failures are are fixed in a day or
two, you're saying there can't be any shutdown process at all.

>If you want a really simple, and probably very effective first step- 
>then stop domain tasting. It doesn't help anyone but the phishers.

Actually, I have never seen any evidence that phishers use domain
tasting.  Phishers use stolen credit cards, so why would they bother
asking for a refund?  The motivation for tasting is typosquatting and
"monetization", parking web pages full of pay per click ads on them.
Tasting is a bad idea that should go away, but phishing isn't the
reason.

R's,
John