North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: BGP terminology question

  • From: James Aldridge
  • Date: Tue Nov 08 09:40:46 2005

NetSecGuy wrote:
> I understand AS3333 is RIS itself, is this some kind of misconfig on their
> end? It seems to be announcing it's entire table every 5 minutes. This
> started late Friday and ended a few hours ago.

FYI, AS3333 is the RIPE NCC's production AS; the RIS project uses AS12654.

There seems to be a difference between the behaviours of Cisco and Juniper
routers when encountering the RIS's default keepalive value of 0.  Cisco
routers (and Zebra/Quagga boxes) seem to operate quite happily without
keepalive processing while Junipers seem to tear down and restart the session
after the holdtime expires -- result: 170,000 or so additional updates every
holdtime-and-a-bit seconds.  [Aside:  shouldn't the session be refused at
startup if a mutually agreeable keepalive value can't be negotiated rather
than being allowed to flap like this?]

This problem seems to occur when any RIS peer migrates from Cisco to Juniper.
The only difference this time is that both ASes are operated by (different
groups within) the RIPE NCC.