North American Network Operators Group Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical RE: Can a customer take IP's with them?
Since this customer has it's own space now, and as long as it is as large as the NAC space, they can do a simple 1-to-1 NAT at the border. This should minimise the hardship to them drastically. K On Wed, 23 Jun 2004, Jess Kitchen wrote: > > On Wed, 23 Jun 2004, Andy Dills wrote: > > > Actually, I don't think that's the case. ARIN still owns the numbers, NAC > > is just leasing them. Therefore, ARINs rules supercede anything > > contractual between NAC and the customer. > > I may be missing the point here, but the address space in question is > probably of a PA status as opposed to PI - hence they are deemed > non-portable in the first instance. > > Given that the customer has had an alternative block and been given more > than reasonable time to renumber I would say that the ball is firmly in > Alex's court - not his fault if they can't get their sh*t together. > > Just thinking, the easiest way forward might be to simply to refuse to > deaggregate on the basis of "the good of the Internet" - ignoring any > multihomers that NAC may have out of their aggregates, for the sake of > argument. > > Additionally according to the size of the block and filtering, 8001 will > probably up transiting the traffic anyway with no commercial agreement in > place, which is obviously unacceptable. > > I'd dig out initial contract(s) with the customer, as if there was no > clause there specifically outlining ownership of address space (yes, I > know the concept is a fallacy) then you could go with whatever ARIN > recommendation was in force at the time. > > I had some space from way back when which I think was previous to these > sort of issues with regard to portability ('94-95), culminating in a > letter from the RIR involved saying words to the effect of "you should > return the address space for aggregation reasons, but legally you don't > have to" > > Regards, > Jess. > > -- > Jess Kitchen ^ burstfire.net[works] _25492$ > | www.burstfire.net.uk >
|