North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

False information: CEO of Versign facts are wrong

  • From: Sean Donelan
  • Date: Fri Oct 17 08:28:40 2003

http://news.com.com/2008-7347-5092590.html

Quotes Stratton Sclavos:
"The DDOS (distributed denial-of-service) attacks last October on the root
system--hey, there are 13 global copies of that, and they're all
operating. It should scare people that nine of the 13 went down. It's time
for the Internet infrastructure to go commercial. On the core services of
the infrastructure, it's time to pull the root servers away from
volunteers who run them out of a university or lab or some other level.
That's going to be an unpopular decision."


This factoid has been proven false multiple times, in multiple forums over
the last year. Its incredible that a CEO of a company that claims DNS
expertise wouldn't know this was false. One particular "internet
security" company was PINGing the root servers, and some of the root
server operators turned off ping.  The root servers themselves were
unaffected (except maybe one operated by the US Military).

Historically, the only wide-spread failures have been due to NSI operators
screwing up the COM or NET zone files.  Historically, the other network
operators have needed to pick up the load when NSI fell down.

NSI controls two root servers.  Perhaps its time to split those up among
different organizations.  There is no reason why NSI must operate any
root name severs.  NSI moved all the COM and NET zones to seperate GTLD
servers controlled SOLELY by NSI years ago.