North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: brainstorms (Re: dns based loadbalancing/failover)

  • From: Sean Donelan
  • Date: Sun Oct 07 16:58:37 2001

On Sun, 7 Oct 2001, E.B. Dreger wrote:
> Given enough hosting points, overloading becomes rare; I used
> Akamai as a real-life example.  Given that overloading is rare,
> we can focus on failover, and worry less about load-balancing.
> Given that we need only to focus on failover, the problem (and
> hopefully the solution) becomes much simpler.

There are limitations.  It moves the choke points around, in particular
the choke points between providers (upstream, downstream, and peers).
Overloading is a problem, but it is a distributed form of overloading
and harder for people outside to detect.  Akamai gives excellent
protection from overloading as detected by services like Keynote.
To really measure how well it worked, you need a measurement
infrastructure as distributed as the delivery structure.

During the first couple of hours, the systems appeared to need a
lot of human intervention.  Its unclear to me, as an outsider, what
happened during those first few hours.  Was it a problem with people
not using the tools as well as they could, or if things needed to be
re-engineered on the fly.