North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: The Gorgon's Knot. Was: Re: Verio Peering Question

  • From: Sean M. Doran
  • Date: Fri Sep 28 21:44:59 2001

| Other providers never adopted filters, Sprint has since dropped its
| filters.  The Internet is still growing.

Verio adopted filters.  It is Verio's use of these filters
which triggered tonight's whine-fest.

| It even continued to grow faster because Sprint couldn't control its
| own route announcements.

You are confusing exponential post-filter growth of the global 
routing table (for which there is negative evidence) with exponential
post-filter exponential growth of the number of things reachable
through the Internet.

I will not claim a causal relationship.  However, it'd be nice
if there were evidence that the constrained growth the first of
enabled or at least increased the growth of the other, since that
was the entire goal in the first place.

| Its difficult to view the act as altruistic, when in the face of
| impending  doom,

Sprint could always afford new routers, had deployed many,
and was in the process of a defensive upgrade which would
have meant the problem would never have occurred in the first place.

Doom was never going to happen all at once, except to 
regional/national networks that did not/could not upgrade
their routers in time.

However, as noted by others, unconstrained growth would
have made the Internet impossibly expensive to remain
as dynamic as it was then and is today.

| But perhaps we didn't recognize the behavior as a cry
| for help. 

Well, you were either stupid or blind.

| Much like and addict, it couldn't stop itself from prostituting


| Many a politician and religious leader has condemned the
| sinner, only to be found in bed with the sinner themselves.


by implication philanderer

| A hypocritic condemns others for what he does himself.

I call people names too, but my chosen epithets are both on-target and deserved.


| If you really believed the Internet was facing immenient doom, why
| not also save it by also filtering the outbound announcements.  Why
| engage in the very behaivor your condemnded?

This was answered at least twice earlier tonight. Blind or stupid? You tell me.