North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: Forcasts, why won't anyone believe them?

  • From: Sean Donelan
  • Date: Tue Jan 16 23:38:23 2001

On Tue, 16 January 2001, Jeff Cours wrote:
> It might be possible to come up with some sort of average power draw,
> but Electrical Engineers really hate to give out numbers like that
> because people base their designs on them instead of on the worst case
> power draw, and then when something fries the EE winds up getting the
> blame. That's why most engineering disciplines derate components and
> allow a safety margin, which I suspect is where the fuse rating comes
> from.

They may hate to give out this information, but any piece of equipment
with a NEBS level 3 rating already has this information.  I'm not asking
for vendors to do the full, burn the box, NEBS testing.  But having the
power drain data sheet would be very useful.

This is really a customer demand issue.  If customers started demanding
vendors supply a full NEBS-like space and power planning data sheet, we
would get the information.  But customers don't, so we don't.

While this may be a deliberate decision by customers, who would rather
save the money on equipment and spend a bit more on "extra" electrical
infrastructure, I don't think so.  I suspect its because customers have
never known they could ask for such a thing.