North American Network Operators Group

Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index | Thread Index | Author Index | Historical

Re: Is the .to (Tonga) domain completely rogue and should be removed?

  • From: Nathan J. Mehl
  • Date: Thu Oct 01 17:29:57 1998

In the immortal words of Barry Shein ([email protected]):
>  > Barry, this seems sort of silly.  They have a stated abuse policy.  You
>  > have evidence that one of their registrants is operating in contravention
>  > to that policy.  What on earth is preventing you from making the obvious
>  > phone call?
> 
> Gosh that sounds so good Nathan.
> 
> Unfortunately, as of right this minute, 10/1 at 2:20PM EDT, these porn
> domain forgers are back on the Tonga site and spamming away again
> forging our domain name into their spams.

Er, I take it from the "again" that you _did_ try to contact the
Tonic registry?  You're being uncharactistically cagy on this point...

> Something is very, very wrong with the Tongan domain and its
> management. They're not removing criminal domain-hijacking spammers,
> they're just letting them change their name as far as I can tell.

Barry, if they're even doing so much as _that_, that's more than
Network Solutions will do to somebody "abusing" the .com domain.

I'm really mystified by your approach to this.  ".to" is a TLD like
any other.  Your current crop of spammers isn't "on the Tonga site"
any more than Jeff Slayton or Sanford Wallace were "on" Network
Solution's "site".

And your perception that .to is largely or entirely comprised of 
spammers and scam artists is, well, a perception, and one that 
doesn't seem to really line up well with the facts at hand.

Look, I understand that you're frustrated that World is under
attack and that the culprits haven't been shut down yet, but
pointing the finger at their domain registry seems strangely
counterproductive, especially when that registry is doing no
worse (and in some lights much better) than any other TLD in
dealing with abuse issues.

-n

------------------------------------------------------------<[email protected]>
"Reading [James] Ellroy can be like deciphering Morse code tapped out by a 
pair of barely sentient testicles."              (--Dwight Garner, in _Salon_)
<http://www.blank.org/memory/>------------------------------------------------